Is it your turn to submit writing? Do yo want to get high-quality feedback?
Ask for it!
Often it’s not enough (or very strategic!) to just send a colleague a draft text and ask them what they think.
To help your readers, and get the most useful feedback on your writing, it’s a good idea to:
*What is this text (e.g. this is a journal article or a thesis chapter..etc).
Text level: flow of ideas, organization
Paragraph level: cohesion (transitions, flow), level of detail.
Sentence level: grammar, vocabulary items, punctuation, formatting
*Specific language issue that you have been told you need to work on
*Usage conventions (discipline/journal etc.)
Some examples of asking for feedback:
To help your readers, and get the most useful feedback on your writing, it’s a good idea to:
- Provide the reader with some info on the text, specifically:
*What is this text (e.g. this is a journal article or a thesis chapter..etc).
- Specify what you want feedback on, e.g:
Text level: flow of ideas, organization
Paragraph level: cohesion (transitions, flow), level of detail.
Sentence level: grammar, vocabulary items, punctuation, formatting
*Specific language issue that you have been told you need to work on
*Usage conventions (discipline/journal etc.)
Some examples of asking for feedback:
Other tips:
- Specify what you don’t need comments on, eg your referencing, your grammar/spelling.
- While it may make you look good, try not to circulate extracts that you’re happy with or that have been worked on by your supervisor or a copy-editor.
Is it your turn to provide feedback? Here are some tips on how to do it!